Two bags, two different jobs
A wetbag and a menstrual cup pouch are not interchangeable. One is built to contain moisture and odor from used items; the other is a breathable home for a clean, dry cup. The right choice depends on what you need to carry and whether the contents are wet or dry.
The Small Wetbag by Planetwise and the MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton show the difference clearly. One uses a waterproof laminate inner; the other is organic cotton designed to let air move. Neither is a better bag in general—they answer different storage questions.
Material and moisture handling
- Small Wetbag by Planetwise: A high-quality polyurethane laminate (PUL) inner that is anti-microbial and inhibits the growth of bacteria and fungi, plus a 100% cotton outer. The PVC-free interior and lead-free zippers are designed to contain wet or soiled items.
- MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton: Organic cotton, described as breathable and washable to help keep your cup clean and dry between uses. It is not described as waterproof or moisture-proof.
What each bag is sized to hold
The small Planet Wise bag measures approximately 7.5" X 10". That is a useful size for a single cloth pad, a small handful of liners, or a wet swimsuit—but it is not a full-size wet bag for a day's worth of heavy-flow pads.
The MeLuna drawstring pouch is designed to fit all MeLuna cup sizes up to XL with room to spare. It is a cup-specific storage bag, not a general-purpose wet bag. If you need to carry used pads, the pouch is the wrong shape and material for the job.
Evidence for the wetbag's moisture role
- Small Wetbag by Planetwise: PUL inner is anti-microbial and inhibits the growth of bacteria and fungi. This is the feature that makes a wetbag suitable for temporarily holding used cloth pads or other damp items.

Small Wetbag by Planetwise - Small Wetbag by Planetwise: The water repellent retains 95% effectiveness even after 100 washes. Reusability is the point of a wetbag; this gives you a concrete durability expectation for the water-repellent finish.
- Small Wetbag by Planetwise: Approximately 7.5" X 10". Check this against what you plan to carry. It suits a single pad or small items, not a large stash.
Evidence for the pouch's dry-storage role
- MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton: Organic cotton, described as breathable and washable. Breathability helps a clean cup dry between uses, which is the opposite of what a waterproof wetbag does.

MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton - MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton: Designed to fit all MeLuna sizes—up to XL—with room to spare. Compatibility is settled for MeLuna cups, so you do not need to guess whether your cup will fit.
- MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton: Plastic-free storage. If avoiding plastic in your kit matters to you, this pouch meets that preference; the wetbag's PUL inner does not.
Travel scenarios that separate the two
- Carrying a used cloth pad home: Choose the Small Wetbag. Its PUL inner is the moisture barrier; an organic cotton pouch would let moisture through.
- Storing a clean cup between wears: Choose the MeLuna drawstring pouch. Breathable organic cotton is designed to keep the cup clean and dry.
- Packing a cup for a trip: The drawstring pouch is the travel-friendly cup option because it fits all MeLuna sizes up to XL. The wetbag is better reserved for wet or soiled items.
- A day out with reusable liners: The small wetbag can hold a used liner, but its 7.5" X 10" size limits you to a small number of items. Plan to empty it at home rather than treating it as a week-long stash bag.
Where the supplied information stops
Neither listing supplies step-by-step washing instructions, drying temperatures, or a stated waterproof rating for the wetbag. The wetbag is described as water repellent, not waterproof, and the pouch is described as breathable, not moisture-proof. Treat those as the limits of what is confirmed here.
The wetbag listing also does not state whether the small size fits specific pad brands or sizes. Use the 7.5" X 10" measurement as your guide and check it against your own pads before relying on it for a full day.
How to decide
If your main need is reusable pad wet bag storage—containing used pads, liners, or damp cloth—buy the Small Wetbag by Planetwise. If your main need is a menstrual cup pouch for travel or between-use storage, buy the MeLuna USA Drawstring Pouch - Organic Cotton. Many cup users will eventually want both: the pouch for the clean cup, the wetbag for everything wet.
At USD 8.03 and USD 3.11 respectively, the two are complementary rather than competing purchases. Start with the one that matches the item you actually need to store today.


